How to set up a Bloody Mary bar
The Bloody Mary may be the perfect brunch beverage. It’s a great celebratory drink for anything for a noon-kickoff tailgate to Father’s Day gathering. And if you’re hard-core about it, a Bloody Mary can be brunch all by itself. The savory tomato juice-based cocktail is endlessly customizable. Just tweak the seasonings and garnishes—even the liquor—until it makes you happy. You can even have a Bloody Mary bar! We got some tips from Ed Doris, who we met at one of Kansas City’s favorite Bloody Mary destinations, and is now a bartender in Milwaukee, arguably the Bloody Mary Capitol of the U.S.
Inspired? Create and share by tagging @hallmarkstores.
Why do we love a good Bloody Mary?
“It’s savory and kind of a comfort food—and it’s good for getting straightened out after a big night,” Ed tells us. “A Bloody Mary has lots of electrolytes, and it can include your first bites of the day.
“There are places in Milwaukee that make one single Bloody into a buffet,” he adds. “If you want to see engineering projects masquerading as brunch cocktails, search images for ‘Milwaukee’ and ‘Bloody Mary.’”
Impressive–but for a more down to earth libation, we asked Ed for his favorite Bloody Mary base and add-ons.
How to make a Basic Bloody Mary
Here’s Ed’s base Bloody Mary recipe. It’s super-simple and made to be messed with, so it’s best served with a variety of add-ins and garnishes. It’s also a great starting point for your own signature Bloody Mary mix—make a batch and customize it yourself with the ingredients below.
Make your mix the night before and store it in a glass bottle or jar so the flavors blend.
• Start with a quart of your favorite tomato juice.
• Add seasonings to taste—start with about a teaspoon each of salt and pepper
• Mix in a tablespoon or two of savory Worcestershire sauce.
• Add heat with a few splashes of hot sauce.
Serve in a 12 oz. glass.
• Add 1½ oz of vodka (or another spirit of your choice, when you’re ready to experiment).
• Squeeze in about a half ounce of lemon or lime juice.
• Pack the glass with ice.
• Top with your mix.
Then it’s time to make it your own.
How to build a Bloody Mary bar
Add flavor
First, it’s time to punch up the mix.
“Sriracha is killer in Bloodies,” Ed says. “Adding beef broth is a good riff. Get freaky and try Asian fish sauce instead of Worcestershire.”
Along with those, you might provide:
• Celery salt and celery seed
• Different kinds of pepper
• Specialty salts
• Olive brine
• Pickle juice
• Hot sauce
• Soy sauce
• Grated horseradish
Throw in herbs
Another way to add flavor: “Herbs. Fresh herbs. Garnish with cilantro, rosemary or fennel,” Ed recommends.
To get the most flavor, crush the leaves. “Don’t destroy them, but be firm. Roll the sage between your palms; give the cilantro a little pat,” Ed says. “The aroma from the oils makes for an easy next-level addition.”
Start with basic garnishes
“Bare minimum, you want something salty and a cool, crunchy veggie,” Ed advices. A few to consider:
• Jumbo olives
• Celery stalks
• Carrot sticks
• Pickle spears
• Pickled okra
• Brined cheese
Try surf or turf
“Anything that goes well with tomatoes will work,” Ed says. “Seafood is good because of the cocktail sauce feel of the drink. I like BBQ rub with mine.”
So fill out your bar with:
• Beef sticks
• Crunchy bacon strips
• Cooked shrimp (grilled or chilled)
• Lobster claws
• Raw oysters—try them served with mix and vodka in a shot glass
Experiment with spirits
“The great thing about this cocktail is versatility,” Ed says. That means don’t have to limit yourself to vodka—tequila, whiskey, and beer work, too.
And for a true Milwaukee-style Bloody Mary, add a beer chaser—a 4 oz. glass of brew on the side. Ed recommends good domestic pils or lager: “It’s better than cheap bubbles and cleanses the palate just as well.”
Looking for more inspiration? Check out these other ideas:
Shop Barware for Him
See allYou may also like
See more-
Christmas The ultimate Christmas to-do list to help you get a jump on holiday planning
For some of us, the Christmas spirit is a year-round lifestyle. Whether it’s decorating the tree with pretty lights ...
-
Christmas More than decoration: How Christmas ornaments become memory keepers
There are things in life that turn memories into something tangible you can touch: photos, handwritten notes, recordi...
-
Christmas Create miniature magic with the Snowman Village collection!
Our new Snowman Village collection is just waiting to become your family's new favorite Christmas tradition. With new...
-
Mahogany A love letter for Black Thanksgiving
It just dawned on me that we’re the new aunties. I don’t know when this happened because, in my mind, I’m still one...
-
DaySpring The only identity that never fails me
From late March to October, I filter my life through the lens of Major League Baseball, Braves baseball in particular...
-
Christmas DIY Christmas card display ideas
Okay, we’ll admit that if anyone is going to biased in their thinking when it comes to keeping and displaying Christm...
-
Keepsake Ornaments You love Keepsake Ornaments…we love rewarding you! 🥳
Collecting Keepsake Ornaments isn't just a hobby for you—it's a passion! And that kind of enthusiasm is something we ...
-
Christmas The ultimate gift guide for millennials who still quote their favorite Christmas movies
Christmas movie nights are one of my favorite parts of the holiday season. Partly because of the popcorn (it’s basica...
-
DaySpring Nurture your heart to live and believe with joy
Scripture offers us many reminders of the amazing gifts the Lord provides. Complete and reassuring, Paul’s descriptio...
-
Mahogany Savoring fall before the holidays arrive
This season, I’m heading to New England for the first time…specifically Rhode Island, Massachusetts, New Hampshire an...
-
Christmas Keeping Christ at the center of Christmas: Meaningful ways to celebrate Jesus this holiday season
Christmas is a favorite holiday for many of us. The excitement of the first snowfall, Christmas lights and carols, ho...
-
Christmas Comfort in making: Christmas DIY ideas to help you slow down and create meaning this season
There’s just something about the Christmas season—that time of year when everyone becomes decidedly and delightfully ...
-
DaySpring Meet the DaySpring contributors
The DaySpring Writing Community is where women of different ages, life stages, cultural backgrounds and church tradit...
-
Christmas 20+ ideas to help you plan your trip to the Hallmark Christmas Experience
Ever wanted to step inside of a picture-perfect Hallmark Christmas movie? Or travel to a place where you could immers...
-
DaySpring He loves us still
When I received news that our women’s Bible study group at church was going to study the book of Hosea, my spirit sun...
-
Mahogany Carrying memories of homecoming...and how to create new ones
My parents found an old photo of me on the homecoming court at Xavier University. Miss P1, elected to represent my fi...
-
Gifting Why Peanuts still feels like Christmas
When it comes to holiday nostalgia and Christmas comfort traditions, it’s hard to top A Charlie Brown Christmas. At t...
-
Calendar Flip Woo-Hoo—summer’s here! June 2027 holidays and celebrations
Summer is here in all her glory and we are ready. Warm days and cool drinks lay ahead. So it’s time to flip the ca...
-
Calendar Flip Spring Forward: March 2027 Holidays and Observances
Color us excited! From the wearin’ of the green and more sunny fun to colorful Holi festivals and celebrating crayons...
-
Calendar Flip Yay for May! May 2027 holidays and celebrations
Flowers are blooming, students are graduating and moms are getting some well-deserved appreciation. What a fabulou...