Pilgrim hats peanut butter cups

Pilgrim Hats Peanut Butter Cups Recipe

Thanksgiving Pilgrim Hats Peanut Butter cups are perfect for your gatherings with family and friends. This Thanksgiving dessert recipe features miniature peanut butter cups, chocolate wafer cookies and icing. They’re easy to assemble and even easier to enjoy. If you’ve been looking for creative Thanksgiving dessert recipes, then this chocolatey treat is exactly what you need.

Yield: 12 pilgrim hats

Inspired? Create and share by tagging @hallmarkstores.


12 unwrapped miniature peanut butter cups
12 chocolate wafer cookies
1 cup white frosting
Orange food coloring
Small, round decorator tip and decorator bag for frosting


  1. Tint your frosting orange. Transfer orange frosting to a decorator bag with small, round decorator tip.
  2. Place a small dab of frosting in the center of a chocolate wafer and “glue” a miniature peanut butter cup, upside down, to the wafer.
  3. Draw a band of orange frosting around the base of the peanut butter cup and add a square for the band buckle.
  4. Serve them after your Thanksgiving dinner (or place on your guests’ plates as a pre-dinner treat).